FPI Process Cleaning | How to Move Away from nPB and TCE

There are several forms of non-destructive testing (NDT) available to manufacturers of critical components.  Whether for aerospace or automotive engine components, the ability to evaluate components for integrity is vital to both part and system life.  One of the most popular and accepted methods is fluorescent penetrant inspection.

The FPI Process

Fluorescent penetrant inspection (FPI) is a type of dye penetrant inspection where fluorescent dye is applied to the surface of a non-porous material to detect defects that may compromise the integrity or quality of the part.  After the dye is applied to the components, they are viewed under a black light.  The fluorescent dye will remain behind in any cracks, thereby lighting up the flaw in the component.  This process helps reveal any cracks on a part that may not appear to the naked eye.

 

 

Generally, there are two cleaning steps associated with the process.  The first removing all oil and debris from the part to remove any contamination that may be “covering” the indications or “cracks.”  The second cleaning step, a post clean, removes the FPI solution used to find the indications.

Vapor Degreasing with nPB and TCE

The vapor degreasing process using nPB or TCE as the degreasing solvent has been common for many years.  Now that the EPA has increased scrutiny of these solvents, users are searching for alternative solvents they can use in their vapor degreaser.  The solvent degreasing process was used because it is a water-free process. In the past, there has been a notion that the solvent process is best because the process is so easy -- parts go in the degreaser dirty, they come out clean and dry.  Also, some felt that aqueous chemistries would cause the indications to be covered due to poor cleaning or rinsing and poor drying.  Based on our experience with Brulin aqueous chemistries, these notions are myths.  We have many aerospace customers using our aqueous chemistries for pre/post FPI processing.  Either process has proven effective.

SolVantage Flush | A Safe Replacement

If you have a vapor degreaser and want to keep using it for your FPI process, here are some considerations to be aware of regardless of the vapor degreasing solvent you use.

Recently we did some FPI testing with our SolVantage Flush.  The FPI fluid we worked with was Magnaflux  Zyglo ZL67.  The Flush is Brulin's vapor degreasing solvent that boils at 114F.  It is a Fluorinated Trans Blend that has exceptional degreasing capabilities.  Flush proved very effective in removing FPI solution from various surfaces in a vapor-only process.

 

 

 

Left: 316 SS Fittings with dye penetrant (no water rinse) baked on.  Right: Same fittings after Rocket flush solvent cleaning 20 minutes (no water rinse) exposed to UV light to show residue.  Note (green) residue seen in thread valley was easily and fully washed away with rinse water.

 

 

We did observe that over time the solvent became extremely loaded with the FPI solution.

 

Dye penetrant dissolved in the solvent.

 

We also observed that it was possible to re-deposit the FPI fluid onto parts once the solvent was loaded.

 

Clean 316 SS Fitting (left) dipped in “dirty” solvent (right) exposed to UV light.  The dirty solvent can re-deposit contamination back on clean parts.

 

In this case, the customer we were working with used the rinse water from their aqueous process to remove the FPI fluid.  To keep the FPI fluid from re-depositing on parts during processing, I would recommend the following.

How to Reduce Soil Re-Deposition

Step 1:  Hang the basket of parts in the vapor zone over the boil sump. This will allow a vast majority of the FPI fluid to drip directly into the boil sump.

Step 2:  Immerse the basket into the rinse sump with ultrasonics to remove all soils remaining on the part. What little FPI solution is removed should quickly find its way to the boil sump due to the continuous distillation process within a vapor degreaser. 

Step 3:  When introducing FPI solution into the degreaser, you may consider more frequent boil downs or distillation of the boil sump. This should completely remove this soil from the degreaser.

Final Thoughts

As nPB and TCE starts to become banned in states and the supply slows, many companies will be forced to look for environmentally and worker safe alternatives.  SolVantage Flush has been proven to easily clean pre and post FPI inspection while helping to reduce FPI soil build-up.  Solvent technology will continue to develop and provide better alternatives as nPB and TCE for parts cleaning are eliminated.